Amodini's Book Reviews

Book Reviews and Recommendations

Audiobook Review : The Punishment She Deserves by Elizabeth George

Written By: amodini - Jun• 05•19


Title : The Punishment She Deserves
Author : Elizabeth George
Narrators : Simon Vance
Genre : Mystery
Publisher : Penguin Audio
Listening Length : 22 hours 48 minutes
Rating : 5/5
Narrator Rating : 5/5

Ever want to get down on your knees and give thanks to the good Lord for creating a fabulous writer (and hence his/her fabulous books)? I kid you not 🙂 if there ever was such a time, it was when I finished this book. The Punishment She Deserves is that book – a perfect, magnificent mystery, and fully deserving of the 5/5 rating!

Young and altruistic Ian Druitt, Ludlow’s deacon, is accused of a heinous crime, and dies while in prison. The death is sudden and unexpected – and appears to be a suicide. Detective Chief Superintendent Isabelle Ardery and Seargent Detective Barbara Havers are dispatched to the scene, but while Ardery is well-satisfied to quickly wrap up the case, Havers goes sniffing around and finds numerous oddities and holes in the story. Ardery however overrides Havers’s objections and they return.

When Ardery’s unsatisfactory handling of the case, and her downward spiral into alcoholism comes to light, Sergeant Detective Barbara Havers is then dispatched a second time to Ludlow, this time with the dashing Detective Inspector Thomas Lynley. Havers now has full freedom to explore, and use her instincts to unravel this confounding mystery.

This is my first book by Elizabeth George but it certainly won’t be my last. I hope all her books are as good because “The Punishment She Deserves” sets a high bar. This book is detailed and meticulous and strewn with red herrings. George leads us on, revealing the truth little by little. Her characters are fabulously drawn. Havers and Lynley are an extremely likable pair, quirks and all. The book is almost 23 hours long, and they were 23 well spent hours!

Simon Vance gives voice, and he is just as fabulous as the book. Highly, highly recommended!

Audiobook Review : Today Will Be Different by Maria Semple

Written By: amodini - May• 22•19

Title : Today Will Be Different
Author : Maria Semple
Genre : Contemporary
Narrators : Kathleen Wilhoite
Publisher : Hachette Audio
Listening Length : 6 hrs 28 min
Source : Library
Rating : 2.5/5

Like Semple’s previous book “Where’d You go Bernadette”, “Today Will be Different” also has an eccentric/quirky housewife for a protagonist. She, Eleanor Flood, also lives in Seattle with 1 husband and 1 child (it is a son this time instead of a daughter), and she was also a genius artist/illustrator a long time ago (Bernadette was an architect). The book which spans a day in Eleanor’s life covers her life, her relationships and her desire to make this new day count.

Today will be different. Today I will be present. Today, anyone I speak to, I will look them in the eye and listen deeply. Today I’ll play a board game with Timby. I’ll initiate sex with Joe. Today I will take pride in my appearance. I’ll shower, get dressed in proper clothes, and change into yoga clothes only for yoga, which today I will actually attend. Today I won’t swear. I won’t talk about money. Today there will be an ease about me. My face will be relaxed, its resting place a smile. Today I will radiate calm. Kindness and self-control will abound. Today I will buy local. Today I will be my best self, the person I’m capable of being. Today will be different.

The plot is a bit wishy-washy. I can sorta sum it up as being about acceptance of oneself and others and life as it is (not as it should be). That said, I will say that I came close to giving up on this book and DNFing it. For one, the context switches are surreal. The protagonist jumps about from one far-flung thought to another and if you’re listening to this as an audio-book (as I was) you lose track if you don’t pay attention (as I’m wont to do sometimes).

There is an undercurrent of humor, which is nice. And Eleanor although loopy, is a good person with faults, just like the rest of us. I kinda felt for her at times and was moved, other times I just didn’t get her impetuous over-the-top reactions. The parts about her relationship with her sister are interesting. The book did move philosophically from point A to point B, but I can’t say that I enjoyed the journey – and there isn’t much to take away from or ponder post-read. I don’t get the hype over this book, so unfortunately can’t recommend it.

Kathleen Wilhoite narrates this book too and is just as good as she was in “Where’d you go Bernadette?”.

Wordless Wednesdays #89

Written By: amodini - May• 08•19

Schwanenplatz, Lucerne

Audiobook Review : Missing Presumed by Susie Steiner

Written By: amodini - Apr• 24•19

Title : Missing Presumed
Author : Susie Steiner
Narrators : Juanita McMahon
Genre : Mystery
Publisher : Random House Audio
Listening Length : 12 hours 52 minutes
Rating : 4/5
Narrator Rating : 5/5

Missing Presumed is Book 1 in the Manon Bradshaw novels. Book 2 is out already and I hope there are many more coming because Missing Presumed was great.

Detective Sergeant Manon Bradshaw is a single, 39 year old policewoman out to solve the case of missing 24 year old Cambridge student Edith Hind. The pressure is on, because the first 72 hours are crucial and also because Edith’s father has some clout – he’s friends with the Home Secretary. The mystery is a hard one to solve – time passes by with Manon none the wiser.

Now there are murder mysteries galore, but this book (and hopefully all of Steiner’s work) stands out because of the depth she gives to her characters. Manon Bradshaw is a fully-fleshed out protagonist. It is almost like the book is about Manon with a mystery thrown in as a bonus. The book starts out by recounting one of Manon’s blind dates, one that doesn’t quite work out. Manon is lonely but hopeful; she is out dating almost everyday hoping she’ll meet the one.

It is not just Manon who is so well-sketched out. We get to know the victim a little, and there are some musings from Edith’s mother Miriam who is also lonely but in a different way. Then there’s Manon’s colleague Davy, her boss Stanton and potential boyfriend Alan.

The mystery itself ended a bit under-whelmingly, but I’m looking forward to reading the next Manon Bradshaw novel because I like her strong, brave character and I also appreciate the details about the other people in the book. It makes them come to life, gives one a feel for them, so to speak, and gets me invested in seeing the mystery to its end.

Missing Presumed has a “literature” like feel to it, which is kind of rare (Tana French’s work comes to mind). I like that Steiner takes her time in getting to the crux of the matter, an it was a real pleasure listening to Juanita McMahon give voice to it. Highly recommended.

Wordless Wednesdays #88

Written By: amodini - Apr• 10•19

Qutb Minar, New Delhi

Audiobook Review : The Road by Cormac McCarthy

Written By: amodini - Mar• 27•19

Title : The Road
Author : Cormac McCarthy
Genre : Sci-fi (Post-apocalyptic)
Narrators : Rupert Degas
Listening Length : 5 hours
Rating : 4.3/5
Narrator Rating : 5/5

The Road is a post-apocalyptic novel, and it has for the most part only two characters a father and a son. Neither is named – the father is just “the man” and the son is just “the boy”. Both are walking towards the oceanside towns and to do this they must pass through deserted, burned through cities. We don’t know why the world is in this condition, but we realize that most of humanity has been wiped out. Those that remain compete for resources, stealing, killing and cannibalizing for survival.

McCarthy describes the pitiable condition of the two. Food, water and medicines are scarce. They have very few belongings which they store in a shopping cart that they pull alongside as they walk. They forage though deserted homes to replenish their meager supplies of food, and clothes, and keep a low profile to avoid detection by hostile gangs of marauders.

“The world soon to be largely populated by men who would eat your children in front of your eyes and the cities themselves held by cores of blackened looters who tunneled among the ruins and crawled from the rubble white of tooth and eye carrying charred and anonymous tins of food in nylon nets like shoppers in the commissaries of hell. The soft black talc blew through the streets like squid ink uncoiling along a sea floor and the cold crept down and the dark came early and the scavengers passing down the steep canyons with their torches trod silky holes in the drifted ash that closed behind them silently as eyes. Out on the roads the pilgrims sank down and fell over and died and the bleak and shrouded earth went trundling past the sun and returned again as trackless and as unremarked as the path of any nameless sisterworld in the ancient dark beyond.”

The man, a good guy as he puts it, only wants to protect his child, but the son is still innocent of the horrors of the world and is completely dependent on his father for survival. That survival is tenuous and their journey is fraught with danger.

What gets me about this novel besides the edge-of-seat tension that I usually experience only while watching movies, is the depiction of fatherly love. It is deep and pure and constant and heart-wrenching to witness, especially when you know that the father must realize the hopelessness of their condition but still remain stoic and hopeful for his son’s survival. My heart went out to him.

I didn’t see the movie because I though it’d be hard watching the hapless plight of a 9 year old, but the book isn’t any easier – essentially McCarthy does a marvelous job of conveying to us the hopelessness of the situation.

This Pulitzer-winner is a dark and grim novel to listen to, but it is beautifully written. Narrator Degas is fabulous to listen to, since he conveys to us the harsh truth of survival, the father’s grim resolve and the innocence and purity of the boy. Degas’s narration won the AudioFile Earphones Award.

Wordless Wednesdays #87

Written By: amodini - Mar• 13•19

Solomon Northup marker, New Orleans

Audiobook Review : Everybody’s Fool by Richard Russo

Written By: amodini - Feb• 27•19

Title : Everybody’s Fool
Author : Richard Russo
Genre : Fiction (Contemporary)
Narrators : Mark Bramhall
Publisher : Random House Audio
Listening Length : 18 hours 53 minutes
Rating : 4.2/5
Narrator Rating : 5/5

Everybody’s Fool is the sequel to Nobody’s Fool and was written a good 10 years after that released. It is situated in the same small fictional town of North Bath with just about the same cast of characters – Sully, et al., except this time the main character, the man who considers himself everybody’s fool is Police Chief Doug Raymer.

Raymer was a minor character in Nobody’s Fool but here takes center stage as a man with serious thoughts of depression. Raymer’s wife, whom he believes he was lucky to marry (she apparently being way above his league) was about to leave him for another man when she died of a fall down the stairs. His grief at her loss is tempered by feelings of jealousy and betrayal. She made a fool of him but he has not been able to let go of her, and the anger has now turned into self-loathing. Things must come to a head, and we keep building up to it during the course of this novel.

We also get to hear from Sully. Since Nobody’s Fool he’s risen up in the world (relatively speaking), his relationship with son and grandson has improved but his health has suffered – he has about 2 years until his heart gives out, per the VA cardiologist. There’s also Rub Squeers, who’s waging a minor battle to still remain Sully’s “best friend”, Carl Roebuck, Sully’s erstwhile boss, who’s had a fortune reversal, and Sully’s on-again-off-again mistress Ruth, her daughter Janey and her abusive, no-good of an ex-husband Roy Purdy.

These are all intricate threads of the same story, and Russo, master storyteller that he is, keeps them all twanging heart-achingly, fleshing out their lives perfectly. Everybody’s Fool is populated (just like the rest of his books are) by everyday, ordinary characters struggling with their personal challenges, making decisions some good, some bad. Russo makes every one of these characters real, so that we are completely invested in Sully and Raymer and the rest of their cohorts.

While Empire Falls remains my favorite, Everybody’s Fool comes a close second. It is gorgeously written, beautifully detailed and progresses at a decent pace (something I thought Nobody’s Fool lacked). Narrator Mark Bramhall is an absolute marvel! Highly recommended.

Wordless Wednesdays #86

Written By: amodini - Feb• 13•19

Ceiling Detail, St. Louis Cathedral, New Orleans

Audiobook Review : Nobody’s Fool by Richard Russo

Written By: amodini - Jan• 30•19

Title : Nobody’s Fool
Author : Richard Russo
Narrators : Ron McLarty
Genre : Fiction
Publisher : Random House Audio
Listening Length : 24 hours 53 minutes
Rating : 4/5
Narrator Rating : 5/5

There comes a time when you try book after book, but none hook you enough to go beyond an hour of listening time. Then you need a dependable author, one you know has the skill to put together a real tale. So you turn to Richard Russo.

Nobody’s Fool is about Donald “Sully” Sullivan, a 60 year old out-of-work construction worker with a bum knee, a broken marriage and an estranged son. Good-natured, easy-going Sully is well-liked around the small town of Bath, New York where everyone knows everyone and has for a long time. He rents out the top floor flat from his old English school teacher Mrs. Beryl Peoples, doing odd jobs for her and looking in on her from time-to-time. Other people populating Sully’s world are co-worker Rub Squeers, tight-fisted boss Carl Roebuck, mistress Ruth, ex-wife Vera, and son Peter.

We meet Sully as he goes about finding work with Rub, lunching at the local diner, and playing poker with his one-legged lawyer friend Wirf who’s trying to get him disability benefits. Sully has issues, even though he pays them little mind, and his obstinate streak won’t let him be guided by good reason, something his astute and sharp-tongued mistress points out to him again and again. Sully is nobody’s fool, but he does have a penchant for meandering (even while resisting) his way through all the conflicting, intricate little threads of problems that surround him.

Russo gives us minute descriptions, of the locales, the people, and their behaviors. The character development is well nigh perfect! His story telling is compassionate; his words even while poignant and truthful are interspersed with wit and wry humor. But of course, such expansive descriptions lend themselves to long, leisurely stories, and this is no different. Like “Empire Falls” Russo builds up his story slowly, so we get to hear of and about Sully in little bits and pieces, even though those bits and pieces are seamlessly knit together. There is no big over-arching plot or a clear resolution to that plot in this book. If you are looking for a clear-cut plot-driven, climax-filled book, this is not the one.

I will say that I listened to the book in fits and starts because the build-up went on too long for me. It sped up around Hour 7 and after that I plowed through it. I will also say that even though I would drop this for a couple of days, every time I picked it back up I would be immersed in the story, and again in awe of Russo’s skill!

Ron McLarty delivers impeccable narration to go along with this gorgeous book. Nobody’s Fool is like Empire Falls, almost perfect (even though that was much more fast-paced), and a book that will stay with you a long, long time after reading or listening to it.