Amodini's Book Reviews

Book Reviews and Recommendations

Best Movies of 2005

Written By: amodini - Dec• 23•05

I’ve updated the Best Films by Year page with the Top 10 movies of 2005. Looking back I see some really good films in the Best Films of 2005 ; Paheli, Sarkar , Sehar – you name it we got it – The Best of the Best ! Desi cinema sure is going places. Check it out to see if your favorites feature in it !

Categories : _films , _film_reviews

The short story

Written By: amodini - Nov• 16•05

I’ve been reading short stories lately, and here are links to a few famous ones online :

The diamond necklace (Guy de Maupassant)
Hills like white elephants (Hemingway)
A clean well-lighted place (Hemingway)
A good man is hard to find (Flannery O’Connor)
The open window (H.H.Munro)

I haven’t been able to find “Cathedral” (Raymond Carver) online. Out of the above, “The diamond necklace” is my absolute favorite. I’d read it many years ago in a volume of Maupassant’s collected short stories, and the online one seems to have slightly different language. Nonetheless, the story loses none of it’s impact.

Some good links to read more short stories on the net are :

Classic Reader Website
Storyglossia website
East of the Web

Horror and comedy

Written By: amodini - Nov• 14•05
In this famine of (decent) Hindi films, I succumbed to seeing , and , two vastly different movies. Constantine, which was released a few months agon, is a horror film, a translation of the comic-book to screen. Keanu Reeves plays the demon hunter John Constantine, who’s chain smoking himself to sure death and Hell. John meets up with policewoman Angela (Rachel Weisz), whose twin-sister Isabel has committed suicide while in a mental facility. Convinced that Isabel saw the super-natural (be it demon or angel) and was pushed to her death, Angela wishes to team up with Constantine and redeem her sister’s soul. What follows is drama, demons and disorder.

Some special effects, like those wings on earthly angels are eye-popping. An interesting watch.

“Eulogy” (2004) on the other hand is touted as a “hilarious” comedy, about a dysfuntional family whose patriarch has suddenly died, thereby summoning all the children under the same roof, for the last rites. So, the siblings gather, along with partners and kids, and discover that the old man, even though dead, has more secrets in store. And while this is not rip-roaringly funny, it has some good gags. Not my first pick in the video store, but if you’ve seen the rest, you can see this one.

Categories : _films , _film_reviews

Cinematic trash

Written By: amodini - Nov• 14•05
Namrata Joshi has an interesting article in Outlook on vulgarity making it big-time in Hindi movies. It’s now mainstream. She writes about “Kya kool hai hum” , “Maine pyar kyon kiya”, which I saw, and “No entry”, “Shaadi No. 1” which I have had the good fortune of not seeing.
Categories : _films

Of super-heroes and detectives

Written By: amodini - Nov• 07•05
I’ve waited a while to see “Batman begins”, so my expectations were high. I have always liked the Batman films, even though he’s probably the only super-hero to actually be like a billionare. You take a protagonist and imbue him with riches, and boom! all the sympathy you felt for the guy vanishes. Why ? OK, you have Spiderman, who’s actually resorted to delivering pizzas, Superman who’sa news reporter always stretched for time, and you think OK, these guys are “noble”, ie; they’re fighting evil inspite of the odds in their personal lives. Now Batman, he’s got this humongous home/castle, a faithful butler, a great outfit, a snazzy Batmobile, AND pots of money, I mean he isn’t really worried about where his next meal is coming from, is he ? Surprisingly, Batman’s still likeable, probably his orphanhood, and the pathos thing coming into play here.

The above protagonist fundas go for explaining why as a kid, I totally abhorred Nancy Drew, disliked the Hardy Boys, but found the “The Three Investigators” interesting. Nancy lived in a nice home, was good-looking, mature, kind, understanding (oh, kill me now !), had a handsome boyfriend, and a rich lawyer father to boot (he was the one who provided Nancy with new cars whenever the old ones got stolen etc.). Ditto for the Hardy boys (reverse the gender). The 3 investigators were, granted not poor, but had limited means, they biked everywhere – not old enough to have licences. Definitely not rich, they didn’t have familial support for detective work, and pretty much depended on their smarts to see them through.

Anyway, coming back to “BB”, it reminded me of “Judge Dredd”, fragmented and slow-paced, at least in the first half. Actually I think a faithful translation of the comic format, it doesn’t work well in cinema. This really begins from the very begining, really taking you through Bruce Wayne’s life as a child, his fear of bats, the death of his parents and the problems he faces thereafter. Liam Neeson was a misfit, I thought, but Michael Caine was perfect as Alfred. Parts of the story seemed very theatrical, and far-fetched, but on the whole an OK watch for Batman fanatics.

The Bold and the Sleazy

Written By: amodini - Nov• 04•05
It’s the reign of television and television channels. As news becomes more insipid and emotions over-done on Star News, Star One offers some hope, in the form of innovative stand-up comedy shows like “The Great Indian Laughter challenge” and “The Great Indian Comedy Show”, which is styled along the lines of American “Saturday Night Live”. Sajid Khan offers his own brand of comedy on the quiz show “Super Sale”. The guy is funny. And while I’m glad that Indians finally have a glimmer of a sense of humor on TV, it’s a little troubling to note that this is coupled with sexist/chauvinistic attitudes.

Take for example “The Great Indian laughter Challenge” which has as it’s judges Shekhar Suman, and the odious Navjot Singh Sidhu, and as it’s hostess the beautiful Parizad Kohla. Now this is a comedy show targeted at a family audience, aired at prime-time. While Ms. Kohla is indeed beautiful, would it be too much too ask that Suman and Sidhu keep their wolf-whistles to themselves ? On one show that I watched, Suman and called her a “pataka”, “phuljari”, “sonyo”, “malai de golyo”, and went on ad nauseum about how she stirred their senses. These are (in case you didn’t get it) Hindi and Punjabi adjectives which border on the offensive/sleazy and should not preferably be inflicted on show-hostesses. I’m not sure Ms. appreciates being subject to this kind of adulation on camera, although she keeps the smile firmly plastered on her face.

It is a problem that 2 grown men, with wives and kids no less, can behave like little boys eyeing candy, and apparently not offend any sensibilities. Is it OK now, to make salacious comments at women ? When exactly will we get offended ? When such shows air on TV and are watched by the millions that do see these programs, what kind of an image of “culture” do they project ? Suman and Sidhu are apparently unaware that this is sexual harassment and should Ms. Kohla call them on it, she would have sufficient proof.

Some guys I talked to about this, advised me to cool it, after all it is a joke, they aren’t doing it in seriousness. Apparently we all should cool it, until the specter of our sisters/wives becoming show hostesses and being subject to such treatment, emerges.

On another note, take “Super Sale” which recently changed it’s hostess from Neeti Mohan, to a more statuesque Ms. Tur (don’t know her first name). I would term this show also a “family” show, where the nicley-dressed but oomph lacking Ms. Mohan fit nicely. Ms. Tur on the other hand, while full of repartees for Khan’s comments, comes dressed more often than not in mini-skirts and mid-thigh concoctions. Khan often makes comments on her “hotness”, although couching it in comic terms. How this makes sense on a quiz show who’s contestants come from the middle class, and often comprise women, I’m not sure – but apparently sex sells. If this is to appease the male section of the audience, where is the female audience appeaser ? Should we campaign to replace Khan with a more visually appealing version ?

The noble and the ig-noble

Written By: amodini - Oct• 26•05
The Ig Nobles were awarded this month. A winner would be someone who “has done something that first makes people LAUGH, then makes them THINK.” According to the Ig Noble organisers, the products of the awardees efforts are “achievements that cannot or should not be reproduced.” These awards are presented by genuine Nobel prize winners, at Harvard University.

One of this year’s awardees is 25 year old MIT student Gauri Nanda, who invented Clocky, a clock which can run and hide. It’s a furry looking contraption, with 2 wheels, which help it roll and hide (everytime in a different place) once the Snooze button is pressed. Ms. Nanda’s inspiration comes from pet kittens which would bite her toes forcing her to wake up.

Also among the 10 awardees are E. Cussler and B. Gettelfinger for their research into the confounding mystery of whether people swim faster in syrup or water ?”

The online dictionary defines ignoble as :

1. Not noble in quality, character, or purpose; base or mean.
2. Not of the nobility; common.

We want more, more, more ….

Written By: amodini - Oct• 25•05
I’ve watched a couple of episodes of “Men Maange More” on Star One, and its hosted by Yudhishtir (or Yudi as he calls himself) a former Channel [V] veejay. Touted, I think, as the metrosexual man’s guide to gadgets, gizmos, fashion and all things hip, it elevates superficialness to an art form. The latest plasma TV, the snazziest Mercedes coupe and the trendiest digital camera are all reviewed for your viewing pleasure and your purchasing power. Got extra moolah ? Spend it on this BMW ! Dangle on your wrist these oh-so-cool watches which will oh-so-impress the ladies ! Be a real man – accesorize !

I am not sure who this program targets – the super-duper rich of India, the stars, socialites, the Page 3 people, the ones who need guidance when buying that 5th or 6th car to stock up that 10 car garage ? Is Star One beamed to only such homes ? Honestly, I have no problems with the content if that content is honestly potrayed. But to purport to be a fashion-passion entertainment guide for THE man, when all it really is is prettied up advertisements for extremely expensive products, is a farce, and chock-ful of artifice.

Actually shouldn’t really be complaining – haven’t we heard the same thing, only targeted at women for ages ? So now men too are climbing onto the bandwagon. Then, what really is the problem ? It’s vague, amorphous and takes different forms, but it encompasses all those programs, books and magazines, which sell you the look, an external look and the message that upon gaining the look, hitherto unlocked doors will open and the poor schmuck will gain entrance into the upper echelons of whatever he/she is aiming to get into. Yes, clothes (and bikes) maketh the boys. But only marginally so. Brains and common sense maketh THE man.

My problem is not with money either. It is an important accesory, that which makes the world go around. It is the flaunting of money, and the in-your-face distinction that “MMM” makes between the haves and the have-nots that churns my stomach. With programs like “MMM”, India and it’s populace seem to be on the fast-track to commercial consumerism. It’s like flying without having walked first. In it’s unabashed marketing aimed at the super-rich, only-the-moneyed-can-be-cool attitude, and it’s unashamed puffery, “MMM” makes itself odious and the bane of sane television.

Categories : _media

The Kite Runner

Written By: amodini - Oct• 24•05
The Kite RunnerThis is the first novel by Khaled Hosseini, and I’d describe it as stunning. And I actually mean stunning – I’m not saying it for effect. Once in a while you read a novel where the prose is so clear, that each word has impact, and you can see the events unfolding before your eyes. The “Kite Runner” is one such. Hosseini’s language is not overtly florid, but he describes things very skillfully. The story ofcourse is compelling and the novel develops beautifully.

The story is told from the narrator, Amir’s point of view (first-person). Amir is the son of a rich merchant in Afghanistan, and good friends with Hassan, the son of their domestic servant, Ali. Amir is Pashtun (higher class) while Hassan is Hazara (lower class). Also Amir is Sunni while Hassan is a Shia. Both boys are motherless, and spend time playing and kite-flying, where Amir flies the kites, and Hassan is the “runner” (the one who runs to fetch kites which have been cut down in kite-duels). Hassan is a good and loyal friend, while Amir though good has a weak streak. Stiuations develop which test this friendship, and change it, and the story wends it’s way through Amir’s growing years, his journey to America, and his one final return to Kabul.

The Chosen (Ballantine Reader's Circle)This is a story of fathers and sons, friendships, betrayal and redemption. The words stick in your head, and I found myself thinking about this novel many days after I’d read it. The only other novel which has had this effect on me is “The Chosen” by Chaim Potok, and I read that many years ago. “The Chosen” and are similar in that they both are stories of friendship between 2 boys. In “The Chosen” they are Jewish teen-aged kids, Danny and Reuven. Reuven is motherless, while Danny’s mom is not really mentioned much.

I guess a novel that moves you to this extent has many powerful events (and I don’t mean world events, wars etc.) describing people’s lives, and all the tumult and the pain these events bring. People with kids, please be warned that “Kite runner” has some passages which are heart-wrenching and saddening to read. Still, one of the best books I’ve read, I highly recommend it.

Technorati tags : kite runner,

Categories : _books

Recent English Films II

Written By: amodini - Oct• 21•05

Recently seen English films :

– Crash
– Longest Yard
– Sahara
– Monster-in-law
– Guess who
– Coach carter

“Crash” has many characters as protagonists connected together by events, and is a story of each of their lives, and how they are influenced by their race, language, baggage, perception and prejudice. We see obvious perverts, and then we see the flip-side. Done beautifully, this film derives a lot of it’s meat from the concept that everyone is human, and will judge and be judged. Here is Ebert’s review.

The “Longest Yard” is a “TT” film. There’s a good guy, there are bad guys, and we root for the good guy as he rubs the villain’s nose in the mud. Nice ! Besides I like Adam Sandler, he exudes a down-to-earth attitude combined with a quirky sense of humor. “Sahara” is an adventure, very Indiana Jones like, where the protagonists hunting treasure atop a sunken ship, fight the villains in different locales interspersed with the blowing up of boats, encounters with fighters on horses, and the firing of an age old (couple of hundred years) cannon. Again of the TT variety.

“Guess who” and “Monster-in-law” were the hammier films, on dealing with issues of color, and obnoxious kith and kin respectively. Watchable but only just. “Coach Carter” was the heart warmer, based upon the true-story of an African-American coach trying to rouse his community to a better future, and willing to stand by his ideals.